Welcome to Angelina's Pizza & Subs
At Angelina's Pizza & Subs, located in Sarasota, FL, a passion for authentic, homemade food shines through every dish. Family-run and community-oriented, this charming eatery has become a local staple, known for its warm service and dedication to quality. Customers rave about the specialty pizzas, from the flavorful Deluxe to the savory BBQ Chicken, all crafted with real ingredients. The inviting atmosphere and attentive staff enhance the experience, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors. With standout dishes such as fresh garlic knots and delectable desserts like tiramisu, Angelina's is truly a gem worth discovering.
Angelina's Pizza & Subs: Reviews & Ratings
We had high expectations because our friends from Oregon told it was the best pizza they had ever had, and this place definitely didn't disappoint! What impressed me the most was their customer service. They made a slight mistake on the toppings of half of our large pizza, but they noticed the mistake before they brought it out and ended up giving us about 3x the amount we ordered, showering us with free drinks, free desserts, and two additional small pizzas. We learned from the owner that they are a family-run business with wife, husband, and two daughters all working there. As we were there eating, it was neat seeing very regulars come in and be addressed by name. They were extremely busy, but it was obvious they really cared about their customers. Oh yes, the pizza and everything else was amazing!! I almost forgot to mention that. Our favorite was the meat pizza.
First time dining at Angelina’s. What a cute little pizza shop with big impact! This place has a great menu! If you have not ordered from here yet you are missing out.
I just tried Angelina's pizza for the first time..If you enjoy fresh pizza and garlic knots made with real ingredients that you can see and taste, then this is a great spot. The owners take pride in serving you real food with real ingredients, minus all the unnecessary sugars and salts. I enjoyed my food and I'll be back soon!
Great pizza made by even better people. The food is always fresh and delicious, and the service is warm and welcoming. A local gem that's definitely worth supporting. You would be doing yourself a disservice by skipping this spot.
There was a glitch with my web order today being “scheduled” and the shop not receiving it right away. If you see this happen on a web order, don’t stop there, get it figured out or call, which I failed to do. I showed up a little before 6:15 today and she didn’t have it. She got with me and their service and figured it out. They all 3 busted their tails to get it ready ASAP and they did. I was a little impatient but it was totally worth it. Everything was cooked perfect, not a small order and tasted fantastic. Great Job Guys!!! Appreciate your hard work and fantastic cooking skills. 5 stars east without question.
Love, love Angelina's! The garlic bites are out of this world! I had the white spinach pizza. My friends had other amazing pizzas with overflowing toppings! The owners were so accommodating with my friend's gluten-free choices! I would definitely go back!!!
Just had an awesome experience at Angelina’s pizza and subs. I ordered the Philly and cheese pizza - absolutely incredible. Do yourself a favor and try it! I also had the garlic bites - the perfect amount of fresh garlic! Fantastic family-owned pizzeria - very friendly!
This was my 1st time ordering from Angelina's. I ordered the Meatball Sub and it was freakin' delicious. :) The lady at the counter was friendly and attentive. The pic I uploaded is only half the sub. Already ate the other.
Location
-
2730 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States Hotline: +1 941-304-1200
Welcome to Angelina's Pizza & Subs, a gem nestled in the heart of Sarasota, FL, at 2730 Stickney Point Rd. This charming establishment is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a family-run business that prides itself on delivering exceptional service and delicious, fresh food. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Angelina's invites you to explore a menu that caters to both traditional and adventurous palates.
- Specialty Pizzas: Their specialty pizzas, like the BLT Pizza and Fire Pizza, are crafted with creativity and care. Each pizza is a canvas of flavors that keeps customers coming back for more.
- Bread Sides: Don’t miss out on the delightful Buffalo Chicken Breadsticks or the heavenly Garlic Knots. These sides complement your meal perfectly and are a must-try!
- Desserts: End your meal on a sweet note with their homemade Tiramisu. It's the perfect treat to satisfy your sweet tooth.
The atmosphere at Angelina's is vibrant, filled with laughter and camaraderie. Regulars are greeted by name, showcasing the personal touch that sets Angelina's apart from the rest. Customers rave about the outstanding customer service, where the staff goes above and beyond to ensure satisfaction. A notable review from Benjamin Miller describes how the team turned a small mistake into an opportunity to impress, showering their table with complimentary items and displaying true hospitality.
If you prioritize quality ingredients, Angelina's offers authentic pizza made from real, fresh components. As Junina McArthur notes, you'll taste the difference in every bite. Each dish reflects their commitment to avoiding unnecessary sugars and salts, offering a healthier yet satisfying dining experience.
In a bustling environment that feels like home, the flavors at Angelina's resonate well with patrons like Adrian Furment, who highlights not only the food but also the people behind it. The combination of fantastic pizzas and a warm ambiance makes Angelina's Pizza & Subs a local treasure. Whether you're a first-time visitor like Kelly Smith or a seasoned regular, you're sure to leave satisfied.
For an unforgettable meal marked by authenticity and a family touch, Angelina's Pizza & Subs is a must-visit. With a menu brimming with flavorful options and a dedication to excellent service, this restaurant has truly carved a niche for itself in the Sarasota dining scene.
So, call them at +1 941-304-1200 or visit today—your taste buds will thank you!